|
By Charlene Crowell | SACOBSERVER.COM WIRE SERVICES
(NNPA) - In the midst of long-term,
double-digit unemployment and millions of foreclosures, many
in America are struggling to financially hold on. But for
others, the plight of the poor is prime time for making money
– and a lot of it.
In Broke USA, author Gary Rivlin shares how
payday lending has become a $33 billion a year ‘poverty
industry’. With small dollar loans typically ranging
from $300-$500, some in America are getting rich off of the
multitudes who are just scrimping to piece together a modest
living for themselves and their families.
In a recent National Public Radio Interview,
Rivlin, a former reporter for The New York Times shared his
reactions to his lengthy study of an industry that preys upon
people with little money and few options for credit.
“To me, the real reason payday has grown
like it has is more of an economic reason than a geographic
reason”, observed Rivlin. “There’s been
stagnating wages among the lowest 40 percent [of wage earners]
in this country, and so they’re not earning anymore
real dollars.”
Continuing he added, “At the same time,
rent is going up, health care is going up [and] other expenses
are going up, and it just becomes harder and harder for these
people who are making$20,000 [or] $30,000 a year to make ends
meet.”
According to research by the Center for Responsible
Lending (CRL), each year, $5 billion is taken from the pockets
of working families to pay for interest on loans from one
of 24,000 payday lenders now in operation – more than
the number of McDonald’s or Burger King restaurants
nationwide. The average payday borrower has nine repeat loans
per year. A $300 loan typically costs $50 in interest by year’s
end, and the customer actually owes more in interest than
in principal.
Further, CRL found that nearly 59 million repeat
payday loans actually account for 76 percent of the industry’s
revenues. And among repeat borrowers, 87 percent occur within
two weeks of a previous loan. Payday lending with 400 percent
interest rates is not a bridge between families’ expenses
and income shortfalls; it is a debt trap that is a fast track
to deeper financial troubles. It is the triple digit interest
rates that wind up forcing customers deeper in debt with every
passing payday.
Worse yet, CRL research further verifies that
this billion dollar growth industry preys most upon communities
of color – black and brown.
In California, the nation’s most populous
state, payday lenders are nearly eight times more concentrated
in African-American and Latino neighborhoods as compared to
white areas. In this one state, $247 million is drained from
working families in fees alone. Even after accounting for
variables such as income, poverty rates and education, payday
lenders were twice as likely to operate in communities of
color.
In Phoenix, Arizona’s largest city, the
same preponderance of payday stores in communities of color
is repeated. South Phoenix, historically the only part of
the city where community people of color were allowed to live,
is also home to the majority of its 211 payday stores. The
same racial pattern also emerged in Tucson, the state’s
second largest city.
On July 1, 2010, the State of Arizona will
sunset payday lending. The successful pro-consumer campaign
that won a voter mandate in 2008 and survived two legislative
attempts in 2010 was recently but cautiously celebrated.
According to Bishop Henry L. Barnwell, pastor
emeritus of First New Life Baptist Church in Phoenix, “It
was a people’s victory, supported and fought on moral
high ground. It was a victory supported by several members
of the Valley’s clergy, who spoke to the immorality
of 400 percent interest rates.” “The payday industry
and its supporters”, concluded Rev. Barnwell, “are
now demonstrating a disregard and disrespect for the will
of the people.”
Bishop Barnwell is absolutely correct. There
is something terribly wrong – and immoral -- about an
industry that celebrates financial success on the backs of
cash-strapped black and brown people.
It is also an industry that smears the credibility
of reputable businesses that practice a different kind of
commerce. When fair prices match with clear transactions,
both businesses and consumers benefit. Real economic development
brings convenient and accessible services and products that
together enhance a community’s quality of life.
Wherever payday lending occurs, however, the
effects are more akin to economic deprivation. Through its
downward spiral of debt, customers have less disposable income
and more cash flow problems as dollars usually dedicated to
daily living are redirected to pay interest and fees.
While communities of color need and deserve
sustainable economic development, it is painfully clear that
payday lending detracts rather than contributes to our quality
of life.
Charlene Crowell is the Center for Responsible Lending’s
Communications Manager for State Policy and Outreach. She
can be reached at: Charlene.crowell@responsiblelending.org.
Charlene Crowell is an NNPA financial writer. |